Eileen's Now....or Then Disaster (February 17, 2010, #5043K)[]
She says it is now.
Unfortunately, she is incorrect.
She says it is now.
Unfortunately, she is incorrect again.
And now, she cannot win the bedroom group.
Joel Plays Now....or Then in Flip Flops (September 30, 2010, #5244K)[]
He says it is then.
Unfortunately, he is incorrect.
He says it is then.
Unfortunately, he is incorrect again.
He says it is now.
He is correct.
He says it is then.
He is correct again.
He says it is now.
He is correct and wins the Beachcomber hot tub!
Now....or Then for a $16,552 Trip to the Nutcracker in New York City (January 6, 2011, #5384K, aired out of order on November 18, 2010)[]
She says it's now.
She is correct.
She says it's now.
She is correct again.
She says it's then.
Unfortunately, she is incorrect.
She says it's then.
She is correct and wins the trip to New York!
David & Jonathon's Now....or Then Disaster (June 17, 2011, #5615K)[]
They said it is then.
Unfortunately, they are incorrect.
They said it is now.
Unfortunately, they are incorrect.
And now, they cannot win the Chrysler 200 LX sedan.
Now....or Then for an $18,368 Trip to Las Vegas (December 22, 2011, #5764K)[]
She says it's now.
She is correct.
She says it's then.
She is correct again.
She says it's now.
She is correct and wins the trip to Las Vegas!
Now....or Then for a $21,795 Dodge Journey SE (June 7, 2012, #6004K)[]
She says it is now.
Unfortunately, she is incorrect.
She says it is then.
Unfortunately, she is incorrect again.
She says it is now.
Unfortunately, she is incorrect. She needs to get the next three correct in order to win.
She says it is now.
Finally, she is correct.
She says it is then.
Sadly, she has lost.
Alexander's Now....or Then Win on the 40th Season Finale (September 6, 2012, #6024K, aired out of order on June 18)[]
He says it's now.
He is correct.
He says it's now.
Unfortunately, he is incorrect.
He says it's now.
He is correct.
He says it's then.
He is correct and wins the groceries and maid service for a year!
Now....or Then for a Honda TRX90X ATV and a Honda PCX150 Motorscooter worth $6,448 (May 31, 2013, #6375K)[]
She says it's now.
She is correct.
She says it's now.
She is correct again.
She says it's now.
Unfortunately, she is incorrect.
She says it's now.
She is correct and wins the ATV and scooter!
Julie's Now....or Then Comeback Win (April 9, 2014, #6693K)[]
It is a trip to Seattle worth $5,065.
She says it is then.
Unfortunately, she is incorrect.
She says it is then.
She is incorrect again.
She says it is then.
She is correct.
She says it is then.
She is correct.
She says it is now.
She is correct and wins the trip to Seattle!
Only Now....or Then Loss of Season 42 (May 28, 2014, #6763K)[]
She says it is now.
She is correct.
She says it is now.
She is correct again.
She says it is then.
Unfortunately, she is incorrect.
She says it is now.
Unfortunately, she has lost.
Now....or Then for a $9,513 Michael Amini Dining Room Group w/Teleflora Monthly Flower Arrangements for 1 Year (June 23, 2014, #6801K, aired out of order on June 27)[]
She says it is then.
She is correct.
She says it is now.
Unfortunately, she is incorrect.
She says it is now.
She is correct.
She says it is now.
She is correct and wins the Michael Amini dining room group!
Michael's Now....or Then Christmas Eve Win (December 24, 2014, #6933K)[]
He says it is then.
He is correct.
He says it is now.
He is correct again.
He says it is now.
He is correct and wins the home theater group!
Now....and Then 2015 & Last Loss on Original Set (September 22, 2015, #7212K)[]
No, your eyes are not deceiving you. Since this is Decades Week, we're using the original title.
And "Then" in this case is September 1980, when it debuted.
He says it is then.
He is correct.
He says it is now.
He is correct again.
He says it is now.
Unfortunately, he is incorrect.
He says it is then.
Unfortunately, he is incorrect and he loses the $5,000 shopping spree.
Now....or Then with a Then Date of October 2007 (October 30, 2015, #7265K)[]
He says it's then.
He is correct.
He says it's now.
He is correct again.
He says it's now.
He is correct and wins the trip to Cleveland!
Another Playing as "Now....and Then" (December 30, 2015, #7343K)[]
He says it is now.
Unfortunately, he is incorrect.
He says it is then.
He is correct.
He says it is now.
He is correct again.
He says it is now.
He is correct and wins the LG washer & dryer with maid service for a year!
Last Appearance of Now....or Then's Original Set (May 20, 2016, #7545K)[]
He says it is then.
He is correct.
He says it is now.
She is correct.
He says it is then.
He is correct and wins the trip to Tuscany!
Debut of Now....or Then's Revamped Set (May 23, 2016, #034SP)[]
Borneo... where the first Survivor season took place.
"Then" in this case is May 2000, when Survivor debuted and was known as such instead of Survivor: Borneo (the actual first season name).
She says it is now.
She is correct.
She says it is then.
She is correct.
She says it is then.
She is correct and wins the trip to Borneo!!!
Daytime Debut of Now....or Then's Revamped Set (June 21, 2016, #7592K)[]
She says it is then.
She is correct.
She says it is now.
She is correct again.
She says it is then.
She is correct!
First Now....or Then Loss on Revamped Set (November 11, 2016, #7685K)[]
NOTE: This is also the only loss of season 45.
She says it is now.
She is correct.
She says it is now.
She is correct again.
She says it is now.
Unfortunately, she is incorrect.
She says it is now.
Unfortunately, she has lost.
Natasha's Now....or Then Car Win (October 13, 2017, #8045K)[]
She says it is now.
Unfortunately, she is incorrect.
She says it is now.
She is correct.
She says it is now.
She is correct again.
She says it is then.
She is correct and wins the Mazda 6 Sport!
Now....or Then for $30,000 & First Loss of Season 46 (February 19, 2018, #8221K, aired out of order on February 22)[]
He says it is now.
He is correct.
He says it is now.
He is correct again.
He says it is then.
Unfortunately, he is incorrect.
He says it is now.
Unfortunately, he is incorrect, and he lost the $30,000.
Second & Last Now....or Then Loss of Season 46 (May 28, 2018, #8361K)[]
He says it is then.
He is correct.
He says it is now.
He is correct again.
He says it is then.
Unfortunately, he is incorrect.
He says it is then.
Unfortunately, he has lost.
Only Now....or Then Loss of Season 47 (April 9, 2019, #8702K, aired out of order on April 2)[]
She says it is now.
She is correct.
She says it is then.
She is correct again.
She says it is then.
Unfortunately, it is incorrect.
She says it is now.
Unfortunately, she is incorrect and the game is over.
Now....or Then for a $5,998 2-Seat Leather Home Theatre Group and a $1,500 Gift Card to Garrett Popcorn Shops (May 15, 2019, #8753K, aired out of order on May 8)[]
She says it is now.
She is correct.
She says it is now.
She is correct again.
She says it is then.
She is correct and wins the home theatre group!
Jaime's Now....or Then Comeback Win (June 7, 2019, #8785K)[]
He says it is now.
He is correct.
He says it is then.
Unfortunately, he is incorrect.
He says it is now.
Unfortunately, he is incorrect.
He says it is now.
He is correct.
He says it is then.
He is correct again.
He says it is now.
He is correct!
Harold's Prize and Phone/Car/Rent Bills Win (September 27, 2019, #8825K)[]
He says it is now.
He is correct.
He says it is now.
He is correct again.
He says it is now.
Unfortunately, he is incorrect.
He says it is now.
He is correct.
He says it is now.
Unfortunately, he is incorrect.
He says it is now.
He is correct!
Now....or Then for an Arctic Cat ZR 200ES Snowmobile and a SpaBerry SB6 Hot Tub worth $14,148 (December 9, 2019, #8931K, aired out of order on March 17, 2020, originally rescheduled to air on July 6, 2020)[]
She says it is now.
She is correct.
She says it is now.
Unfortunately, she is incorrect.
She says it is now.
She is correct.
She says it is then.
She wins the Arctic Cat ZR 200ES snowmobile and the SpaBerry SB6 hot tub!