Pick-A-Number for a Cruise of New England (January 5, 2012, #5784K, aired out of order on October 27, 2011)[]
Pick-A-Number for a Chevrolet Sonic 2LS (May 28, 2012, #5991K)[]
Pick-A-Number for a Harley-Davidson Superlow Sportster Motorcycle (July 2, 2012, #6021K, aired out of order on July 4)[]
Alma's Pick-A-Number Christmas Loss (December 20, 2012, #6144K)[]
Cassidy Plays Pick-A-Number with Nick & Drew Lachey (January 22, 2013, #6192K, aired out of order on February 18, originally rescheduled to air on February 19)[]
Last Pick-A-Number Playing of Season 41 (April 12, 2013, #6305K)[]
Pick-A-Number with the Reversed Colors (November 15, 2013, #6495K)[]
Adam Plays Pick-A-Number in Flip Flops (May 5, 2014, #6731K)[]
First Pick-A-Number Win of Season 43 (December 19, 2014, #6925K)[]
Pick-A-Number for A Trio of HDTVs (February 20, 2015, #7015K)[]
Pick-A-Number for a Trip to Maui, Hawaii (June 25, 2015, #7194K)[]
Pick-A-Number for a Trip to Bocas Del Toro, Panama (November 23, 2015, #7301K)[]
Pick-A-Number for a 2016 Scion iA (January 6, 2016, #7353K)[]
First Primetime Playing of Pick-A-Number (May 24, 2016, #035SP)[]
Pick-A-Number for a Dodge Dart SE Rallye (October 26, 2016, #7663K)[]
Dewey's Pick-A-Number Christmas Loss (December 22, 2016, #7734K, aired out of order on December 19)[]
Pick-A-Number for a Nissan Juke S (May 15, 2017, #7941K)[]
Pick-A-Number for a Honda FourTrax Recon ES ATV and a Yamaha TTR-125 LE Off-Road Motorcycle (October 6, 2017, #8035K, aired out of order on June 29, 2018, originally rescheduled to air on June 25, 2018)[]
Pick-A-Number for a Inspire Fitness Home Gym, a Bowflex Treadmill and a Samsung 65" 4K TV (December 29, 2017, #8145K)[]
Pick-A-Number for a Volkswagen Passat S (February 21, 2018, #8223K, aired out of order on February 19)[]
Alexandria's $20,000 PCH Win (March 5, 2018, #8241K, aired out of order on January 8)[]
Pick-A-Number for a Trip to Puerto Vallarta (June 14, 2018, #8384K)[]
Pick-A-Number for a Trip to St. Maarten (October 31, 2018, #8473K)[]